| Music Creation Method | CD Baby Policy | Action / Consequence |
|---|---|---|
| 100% Generative AI (Text-to-audio: Suno, Udio) | Prohibited | Takedown, account termination, held earnings |
| AI-Assisted Production (Stem separation, mastering, mixing) | Allowed | Must own underlying composition and performance |
| AI Vocal Clones | Strictly Prohibited | Immediate ban without explicit licensing proof |
Why does CD Baby ban AI music?
CD Baby's ban reflects three concerns. First, copyright uncertainty: fully AI-generated works cannot be copyrighted in the US under the human authorship requirement affirmed in Thaler v. Perlmutter. CD Baby cannot protect or collect royalties for content without a clear legal human author. Second, rights compliance: AI generators may have been trained on copyrighted material, creating potential infringement issues that CD Baby cannot independently verify. Third, platform partner requirements: streaming platforms are tightening their own AI policies, and CD Baby has chosen to avoid the risk entirely.